• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • FAQS
  • Privacy Policy

Rants From My Crazy Kitchen logo

  • About
  • Recipe Index
  • Contact Me/Work With Me!
menu icon
go to homepage
search icon
Homepage link
  • Home
  • FAQS
  • Privacy Policy
  • Follow Me!

    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
  • ×
    Home » Baking Experiences

    November 6, 2014

    Baking Experiences: White Christmas Peppermint Cake

    Yesterday I posted a review of Rose Levy Beranbaum's new book, The Baking Bible along with a giveaway of the book and Rose's Heavenly Cake Strips. In the post I mentioned for the millionth time that I'm not a baker, and so I thought I would share the experience with you here today. Let's call this "what happens when a non-baker bakes", or "The Three Day Cake", or "how I can single-handedly turn my life into a disaster" along with a few moments of considering quitting blogging altogether.

    If you read the review, you know I was asked to make the White Christmas Peppermint Cake. Please keep in mind that I am NOT blaming the recipe for the disaster this turned into, I am blaming myself! Let's start at the beginning, it was Wednesday:

    The cake strips. I, who last made a cake maybe ten years ago, had never heard of cake strips. I tried and tried fitting them around my 9-inch cake pans and couldn't get it to work, so as a last resort I decided to go onto Amazon and read the reviews to figure out what I was doing wrong. As soon as I saw the picture I knew. The cake strips are supposed to go on the OUTSIDE of the pans, not the INSIDE!! I don't know why I thought they went on the inside, but I did. Yeah.

    Rose's Heavenly Cake Strips

     

    So, that wasted 20-30 minutes. Next:

    The list of "special equipment" in the recipe calls for parchment rounds and baking spray with flour. My regular grocery store carries neither, so I decided to make my own by cutting parchment paper into "rounds" as good as I could and then spraying with regular cooking spray, sprinkling with just a little flour ( I used cake flour, not regular flour), and rubbing it together with my finger to blend. Um, okay, I can't cut straight.

    making-parchment-rounds

    Somewhere during all this I realized there was absolutely no way I was going to be able to finish the cake, white chocolate custard base, and complete the white chocolate buttercream before I had to get my daughter off the bus, do dishes, and make dinner, followed by the rest of our night. I decided to go ahead with cake anyway and cover it until the next day.

    Making the cake itself was okay, I weighed EVERYTHING,  which is highly suggested in The Baking Bible. Of course, this is a huge part of why I don't bake, I prefer cooking because I can add and subtract ingredients as I feel like, and even change my own recipes the next time I make them. You can't do that so easily with baking. Like my friend Becca told me, you have to love formulas and math in order to love baking, and well, I hate both and pretty much failed them in school.

    The cakes were made, wrapped, and refrigerated for the next day. Great, until the next day when I had already brought out my eggs and butter to come to room temperature, and they had already been out for over an hour, when I made the horrible discovery that I didn't buy enough white chocolate for the buttercream! Are you kidding me??!! I had 8 ounces, and needed 13.2 ounces. There was nothing I could do about it right at that moment, and had to wait until that night to go to the grocery store.

    Friday was Halloween. In the morning, I went to my daughters school parade with my sister and mother, then she had a half day so my sister stuck around to play with her while I made the icing. Well, I got it made, but realized I wasn't going to have enough time to cut the cakes into layers, ice the cake, and take photos before trick-or-treating with friends. So I had no choice but to refrigerate the icing until the next day. This changed the texture of the icing, but it was still usable.

    So Saturday came and by then it was either finish the cake or forget it, it wasn't getting done. That's when I made my next error. I knew I was going to have a problem cutting the cake into layers, but I thought I had the knife right in the middle. What I didn't realize what that the tip of the knife bent up...and sliced right through the top of the cake. That layer fell completely apart when I tried to lift it, turning the cake into a 3-layer cake instead of 4. Good news, that meant the cake had extra frosting and peppermint pieces!

    White Christmas Peppermint Cake

     

    So there you have it, the true story of how making the cake turned out for me. I suppose it could have been much worse, I could have dropped the cake bringing it out to photograph it. Although, looking at these pictures, that might have been a good idea.   Please don't let my experience deter you from trying the recipe yourself, I just wanted to be honest about what happened. I might even make this a semi-regular thing, I try a difficult (for me, not you, I know your laughing at me), likely baking, recipe and post about the experience. What do you think?

    « White Christmas Peppermint Cake-The Baking Bible Review and Giveaway
    Sweet and Sour Pepper and Olive Dip »
    14 shares
    • Facebook12
    • Twitter

    Reader Interactions

    Comments

    1. Serena | Serena Bakes Simply From Scratch says

      November 07, 2014 at 1:55 am

      For all that trouble it gave you, you made it look really tasty!

      Reply

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Primary Sidebar

    Hi everyone!
    Welcome to Rants From My Crazy Kitchen, where I share my favorite recipes and my thoughts on food, picky eaters, products, and restaurants. Join in the fun by subscribing to receive new posts as they are published. You can find out more about me by clicking on my picture. Enjoy!

    More about me →

    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

    Trending Recipes

    • Close up photo of Broccoli Cheddar Pasta Salad
      Broccoli Cheddar Pasta Salad (Walmart Copycat Recipe)
    • Photo of Creamy Cucumber Salad in a large white bowl on a wood table next to a black serving spoon
      Creamy Cucumber Salad
    • photo of a whole pot pie on a baking sheet on top of a wood table
      Chicken Pot Pie
    • Photo of 5 Ingredient Taco Soup in a white bowl topped with shredded cheese and sliced scallions along with a bowl of tortilla chips
      5 Ingredient Taco Soup

    Seasonal Favorites

    • photo of sliced brie on a platter surrounded by fruit
      Baked Brie With Apricot and Walnuts
    • close up photo of a filled and decorated cookie
      Salted Caramel Thumbprint Cookies
    • This Overnight Eggs Benedict Casserole with homemade Hollandaise sauce is perfect for Christmas morning or Sunday brunch. Just a few minutes of prep work the night before and you can have a delicious breakfast ready without any stress in the morning.
      Overnight Eggs Benedict Casserole
    • Slow Cooker Honey Ham

    Hi everyone! Welcome to Rants From My Crazy Kitchen, where I share my favorite recipes and my thoughts on food, picky eaters, products, and restaurants. Join in the fun by subscribing to receive new posts as they are published. You can find out more about me by clicking on my picture. Enjoy! Read More…

    SUBSCRIBE TO RANTS FROM MY CRAZY KITCHEN

    SUBSCRIBE BY EMAIL TO RECEIVE NEW RECIPES AND POSTS WHEN THEY ARE PUBLISHED. YOUR EMAIL WILL ONLY BE USED TO SEND UPDATES.

    Hi everyone!
    Welcome to Rants From My Crazy Kitchen, where I share my favorite recipes and my thoughts on food, picky eaters, products, and restaurants. Join in the fun by subscribing to receive new posts as they are published. You can find out more about me by clicking on my picture. Enjoy!

    More about me →

    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

    Trending Recipes

    • Close up photo of Broccoli Cheddar Pasta Salad
      Broccoli Cheddar Pasta Salad (Walmart Copycat Recipe)
    • Photo of Creamy Cucumber Salad in a large white bowl on a wood table next to a black serving spoon
      Creamy Cucumber Salad
    • photo of a whole pot pie on a baking sheet on top of a wood table
      Chicken Pot Pie
    • Photo of 5 Ingredient Taco Soup in a white bowl topped with shredded cheese and sliced scallions along with a bowl of tortilla chips
      5 Ingredient Taco Soup

    Seasonal Favorites

    • photo of sliced brie on a platter surrounded by fruit
      Baked Brie With Apricot and Walnuts
    • close up photo of a filled and decorated cookie
      Salted Caramel Thumbprint Cookies
    • This Overnight Eggs Benedict Casserole with homemade Hollandaise sauce is perfect for Christmas morning or Sunday brunch. Just a few minutes of prep work the night before and you can have a delicious breakfast ready without any stress in the morning.
      Overnight Eggs Benedict Casserole
    • Slow Cooker Honey Ham

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    • ABOUT
    • RECIPES
    • CONTACT ME/WORK WITH ME!
    • FAQS
    • PRIVACY POLICY

    • Facebook
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

    Copyright © 2025 Rants From My Crazy Kitchen

    Enter your name and email address to subscribe by email
    Stay up to date on all the latest recipes, reviews, giveaways, and more for free!

    Your privacy is important! Please refer to Rants From My Crazy Kitchen's Privacy Policy for information how we use your information and protect your rights.

    14 shares
    14 shares